Paper Trails alternatives: newsletters like it

24 newsletters in the NewsletterFIT index cover the same topics as Paper Trails (Book reviews, Literary fiction and Horror fiction). The closest matches are All Possible Futures, Existential Angst and Plushies - Tim Lieder's Substack and Books & Banter. They are ranked by how many topics they share with it, then by publicly shown subscribers.

Updated Nov 7, 2026 · ranked by shared topics, then publicly shown subscribers · methodology

About Paper Trails

Serious thoughts about books, delivered unseriously

Full profile
  1. 1
    All Possible Futures20K subscribers

    SubstackEvery two weeks · last post 6 days ago

    From recent posts: All Possible Futures publishes monthly book and audiobook recommendations alongside occasional travel essays and media plugs. The content focuses on genres like fantasy, romance, and non-fiction, targeting readers…

    Likely audience: Book lovers

    3 shared topics

  2. 2

    SubstackWeekly · last post 11 days ago

    Tim Lieder writes about books, movies, Judaism., and politics. Currently this substack is discussing John Cheever and the Book of Job (Iyov). His fiction has appeared in Shock Totem and Saturday Evening Post.

    Likely audience: Substack readers

    3 shared topics

  3. 3
    Books & Banter3K subscribers

    SubstackEvery two weeks · last post 21 days ago

    From recent posts: Books & Banter publishes book reviews, author interviews, and personal reading reflections covering horror, speculative fiction, and literary criticism. The publication mixes these formats and targets readers interested…

    Likely audience: Book lovers

    3 shared topics

  4. 4
    Just Reading All Day2K subscribers

    SubstackWeekly · last post 2 days ago

    From recent posts: Just Reading All Day publishes weekly essays on publishing industry economics, literary querying, and agent life alongside book reviews and personal reading logs. The publication targets writers, agents, and readers…

    Likely audience: Horror fiction readers

    3 shared topics

  5. 5

    SubstackMonthly or less · last post 50 days ago

    Likely audience: Book lovers

    3 shared topics

  6. 6

    Substacklast post Jun 18, 2026

    High, Low, and In-between

    Likely audience: Book lovers

    3 shared topics

  7. 7
    Read Your Color222K subscribers

    SubstackEvery two weeks · last post 9 days ago

    Get custom book recommendations that are based on YOUR tastes. Take the assessment at ReadYourColor.com.

    Likely audience: Book lovers

    2 shared topics

  8. 8
    Downtime101K subscribers

    SubstackWeekly · last post 7 days ago

    recommendations & miscellaneous delights for your off-hours

    Likely audience: book lovers

    2 shared topics

  9. 9
    The Reading List63K subscribers

    SubstackWeekly · last post 5 days ago

    A new list of book recommendations or reading how to/guide every Sunday

    Likely audience: Book lovers

    2 shared topics

  10. 10
    BookBrowse60K+ subscribers

    beehiivSeveral times a week · last post yesterday

    Join 60,000+ readers and book clubbers discovering exceptional new releases.

    Likely audience: Book club members

    2 shared topics

  11. 11
    emmareadstoomuch25K subscribers

    SubstackSeveral times a week · last post 6 days ago

    From recent posts: Emmareadstoomuch publishes weekly lists of book reviews, reading habits, and niche literary recommendations for avid readers seeking curated fiction. The publication mixes personal essays on reading strategies with…

    Likely audience: Book lovers

    2 shared topics

  12. 12

    SubstackWeekly · last post 10 days ago

    From recent posts: This publication features essays on writing craft, book reviews, and Christian ministry topics such as church planting and rural life. It also includes practical advice on the writing process and content strategy for…

    Likely audience: Christian writers

    2 shared topics

  13. 13
    Not Special21K subscribers

    SubstackEvery two weeks · last post 21 days ago

    From recent posts: Not Special publishes a rotating mix of personal essays, cultural observations, and curated recommendations covering topics like grief, social media trends, and seasonal lifestyle. The publication targets readers…

    Likely audience: Book lovers

    2 shared topics

  14. 14

    SubstackSeveral times a week · last post 7 days ago

    Women don't vanish after 40. Who knew?! Amplifying and celebrating the voices of women in midlife and beyond by the former editor of Red, Cosmopolitan (and Just 17!)

    Likely audience: Book lovers

    2 shared topics

  15. 15
    Friday Night Readers18K subscribers

    SubstackSeveral times a week · last post 7 days ago

    From recent posts: Friday Night Readers publishes curated book recommendations, literary reviews, and lifestyle guides themed around Gilmore Girls fandom and seasonal reading rituals. The publication targets fans of the show and readers…

    Likely audience: Gilmore Girls fans

    2 shared topics

  16. 16

    SubstackEvery two weeks · last post 37 days ago

    From recent posts: How to Stay with Cait Flanders publishes monthly essays on book reviews, reading challenges, and personal productivity by Cait Flanders, blending literary analysis with reflections on travel, work-life balance, and…

    Likely audience: Book lovers and readers

    2 shared topics

  17. 17
    Content-ment11K subscribers

    SubstackEvery two weeks · last post 5 days ago

    From recent posts: Content-ment publishes a weekly mix of cultural commentary, book reviews, and curated recommendations ranging from AI ethics and historical trivia to travel and food. The newsletter targets readers seeking diverse…

    Likely audience: General readers interested in pop culture

    2 shared topics

  18. 18
    #AmReading9K subscribers

    SubstackWeekly · last post 8 days ago

    From recent posts: #AmReading publishes weekly book reviews, genre-specific recommendations, and author interviews focused on women's fiction, romance, and cozy mysteries. The publication targets readers seeking curated literary…

    Likely audience: Book lovers

    2 shared topics

  19. 19
    book talk with lauren8K subscribers

    SubstackSeveral times a week · last post 5 days ago

    the ultimate bookstack

    Likely audience: Book lovers

    2 shared topics

  20. 20
    Un libro in borsa7K subscribers

    SubstackMonthly or less · last post 8 days ago

    Ciao, sono Alice e ho sempre un libro in borsa. In questa newsletter due volte al mese ti consiglio quelli che leggo e che, secondo me, dovresti leggere anche tu.

    Likely audience: Literature professors and educators

    2 shared topics

  21. 21
    Parenthetical6K subscribers

    SubstackWeekly · last post 4 days ago

    For the girls who'd rather stay home and read a book. Reading lists, curated recommendations, style guides, and tips for romanticizing your everyday.

    Likely audience: Book lovers

    2 shared topics

  22. 22

    SubstackWeekly · last post 10 days ago

    From recent posts: This publication mixes book reviews, author interviews, and essays on themes like immigration, body representation, and religious identity, targeting readers interested in contemporary literary fiction and cultural…

    Likely audience: Book lovers

    2 shared topics

  23. 23
    Ford Knows Books3K subscribers

    SubstackEvery two weeks · last post 11 days ago

    From recent posts: Ford Knows Books publishes weekly book reviews and industry analysis covering literary fiction, self-publishing economics, and specific authors like Laurie R. King and Toshikazu Kawaguchi. The publication targets…

    Likely audience: Book club members

    2 shared topics

  24. 24
    Gratitude Practice3K subscribers

    SubstackEvery two weeks · last post 8 days ago

    From recent posts: Gratitude Practice publishes a rotating mix of personal essays on reading, travel, and parenting alongside book recommendations and author announcements. The newsletter targets book lovers and parents interested in…

    Likely audience: Book lovers

    2 shared topics

Find every newsletter in this space

Search every post these newsletters publish, see who sponsors each one, and get alerted when a new one starts covering the same ground.

Search the index

7-day Pro trial · no card required